“Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.”

Martin Luther King, Jr

Monday, December 12, 2011

Secrecy Bill is Outrageous

The Protection of State Information Bill passed last month by the National Assembly and now awaiting approval by Parliament would make possessing or publishing anything the government feels as "classified" an offense punishable by up to 25 years in prison. Journalists die every day to bring the truth to the world and this is how they are repaid.
African National Congress representative, Jackson Mthembu told the Committee to Protect Journalists that the bill was needed to replace apartheid- era law and safeguard state secrets. He is denying that this is a gag on the media. Mthembu wants the press to strengthen self-regulation to balance better, an individual’s right to dignity, against the media's right to publish. However, this tribunal, answering to parliament is two-thirds ANC and would be tantamount to state control.

Nobel laureate Desmond Tutu and the Nelson Mandela Foundation are opposed to the bill. Agus Sudibyo a member of the Press Council and deputy director of the SET Foundation wants the bill withdrawn because the bill specifics are already included in the 2008 Freedom of Information Law, and criticized the punishment included in the bill.

Under the bill, the leak of highly classified material is punishable by four years in prison and 100 million Rupiah in fines ($11,000), while for classified material it is three years and 50 million Rupiah ($6500). For leaking material categorized as restricted, the given punishment is four years in prison and a 1 billion Rupiah fine. Agus pointed out that the punishments were the same for ordinary citizens and for state officials.

What does this bill really do? It certainly cannot protect secrets that are not even defined, for what can be disclosed that are not classified as secret? This is just another way to hide what is done behind closed doors, another way to hold people down and have no regard for human rights.


FishHawk said...

It sounds like a new dark era in South African history is beginning. It's good to see you back online again.

Relax Max said...

South Africa still uses the Rand. Rupiahs are what Indonesia uses. Are you from Indonesia, blogger? If so, do you really know anything about South Africa or are you yourself part of the propaganda problem? There's plenty of ills for you to attend to in Indonesia, my friend. Leave SA alone.

A. said...

I'm not sure why you feel the need to support South Africa like that, RM, or maybe I do know why. SA has passed a controversial Secrecy Bill, Indonesia is planning to. They seem to have been conflated here but no need to speak to Ettarose like that. Freedom of expression lives?

Susan said...

FishHawk, you know you mean a lot to me, thanks for being here. I have been so busy writing for others I do not take the time to write for myself anymore. I miss it.

Susan said...

Relax Max, to think I used to like you. Unbelievable! I forgot my dear that you were the authority on virtually EVERYTHING. As far as the amount of the fines, unfortunately I can no longer find the article from whence this information originated from. Just to let you know I am not that big of an idiot. Glad you could stop by and yes I am fine, Thank you.

Susan said...

Ahh my dearest A. How I have missed you. So much going on and I have no real reason for not writing. I am going to try, in between school and my writing work I find myself swamped!


Blog Widget by LinkWithin